36 similar games
Games like Mary Had A Lost Lamb
Browser games that play like Mary Had A Lost Lamb, closest match first. Lime means it runs right here.

Mary Had A Lost Lamb is a exploration psychological horror RPG Maker game on a microorganism who is finding her lamb. The games below have the most in common with it — psychological horror, multiple endings, horror — ranked by how closely they match, favouring the ones you can play right here in your browser.
Top picks
The 10 closest to Mary Had A Lost Lamb
- ProphetPlays on cattrigger.itch.io
You are a Pilgrim nearing to the end of your Pilgrimage, committed to the final steps of the ritual with the Great Prophet. In common: body horror, gore, psychological horror.
- My Brother; The ParasitePlays on qrowscant.itch.io
A story about a corpse, a complicated sibling relationship, and the things we forget. In common: abuse, body horror, psychological horror.
- Toxic DreamPlays on reframegames.com
Toxic Dream is a 2D pixel-art survival horror action game about facing anxiety, expectations and grief. In common: psychological horror, exploration, multiple endings.
- Ritual BoundPlays on prsas.itch.io
Deep in the forest, the witches watch over a prison, keeping an Old Horror sealed. In common: gore, psychological horror, multiple endings.
- DoppelpartmentPlays on avdossow.itch.io
You're the building manager of an apartment complex. In common: body horror, psychological horror, multiple endings.
- Gallbladder +++Plays on oxy6.itch.io
Welcome to Gallbladder +++, the short and thrilling experience of the decade! In common: body horror, psychological horror, horror.
- Earn to Die 2Plays here
Earn to Die 2 is a 2D side-scrolling game in which you pilot vehicles that continually improve throughout a zombie apocalypse, literally crushing hordes of… In common: violence, gore, horror.
- Welcome, Dear HumanPlays here
A sentient dating simulator wants you to date monsters - starting with your sleep paralysis demon. In common: psychological horror, multiple endings, horror.
- Down, the Serpent and the SunPlays here
Down, the Serpent and the Sun is a piece of Interactive Fiction written by Chandler Groover. In common: violence, multiple endings, horror.
- What He LeftPlays on romanorm.itch.io
Every night at 3:03, someone knocks on your door. In common: psychological horror, multiple endings, horror.
All matches
Every game like Mary Had A Lost Lamb
PlayableProphet
Retro · 2025
PlayableMy Brother; The Parasite
Psychological Horror · 2023
PlayableToxic Dream
Exploration · 2024
PlayableRitual Bound
Psychological Horror · 2023
PlayableDoppelpartment
Ghosts · 2025
PlayableGallbladder +++
Psychological Horror · 2023
PlayableEarn to Die 2
Zombies · 2014
PlayableBetaWelcome, Dear Human
Psychological Horror · 2026
PlayableDown, the Serpent and the Sun
Violence · 2015
PlayableWhat He Left
Psychological Horror · 2026
PlayableHuman Construction Site
Post Apocalyptic · 2025
PlayableFallen London: Tauroktonos
Ancient Greece · 2019
PlayableIt Paints Me
Psychological Horror · 2023
PlayableMonster Parlor
Psychological Horror · 2023
PlayableRolled: A Pinball Nightmare
Exploration · 2023
PlayableBluebeard: An Interactive Tale
Interactive Fiction · 2022
PlayableDanzai Shitsu II
Psychological Horror · 2023
PlayableThe Judgement Chamber
Psychological Horror · 2021

Fallen London: The Crocodile Who Would Be King
Gore · 2021
PlayableMaimaimai Goen
Psychological Horror · 2021
PlayableFunerama
Psychological Horror · 2026
PlayableBetaI Became an Evil Witch that Cursed the Male Lead
Psychological Horror · 2026
PlayableA man outside
Psychological Horror · 2020
PlayableBe Honest
Psychological Horror · 2023
PlayableMiss Inconspicuous Maid Girl Cleaning Co.
Psychological Horror · 2023
PlayableSilver Thread
Ghosts · 2021
PlayableEarly accessGluttony Gods
Retro · 2023
BetaGenesis
Bloody · 2024
PlayableFlesh, Blood, & Concrete
Gore · 2021
PlayableLakeview Cabin
Exploration · 2013
PlayableAlphaTicuto
Exploration · 2023
PlayableImaginary Spectacle Parade
Psychological Horror
PlayableTo Swat A Fly
Psychological Horror · 2023
PlayableDorotea
Retro · 2025
PlayableStorm the Swan
Psychological Horror · 2024
PlayableIm Null
Exploration · 2014