36 similar games

Games like The Tooth Fae

Browser games that play like The Tooth Fae, closest match first. Lime means it runs right here.

The Tooth Fae cover art

A nightmarish dental simulator where you sneak into townsfolks' homes to steal their teeth. The games below have the most in common with it — atmospheric, creepy, psychological horror — ranked by how closely they match, favouring the ones you can play right here in your browser.

About The Tooth Fae

Top picks

The 10 closest to The Tooth Fae

  1. ProphetPlays on cattrigger.itch.io

    You are a Pilgrim nearing to the end of your Pilgrimage, committed to the final steps of the ritual with the Great Prophet. In common: creepy, psychological horror, atmospheric.

  2. DoppelpartmentPlays on avdossow.itch.io

    You're the building manager of an apartment complex. In common: creepy, psychological horror, atmospheric.

  3. Julia Was AlonePlays on avdossow.itch.io

    Julia is a 19 year old horror fan who dreams of becoming a novelist. In common: creepy, psychological horror, atmospheric.

  4. Generic Fishing GamePlays on ferociter.itch.io

    Sit back and enjoy a peaceful afternoon on the lake, fishing while surrounded by nature. In common: creepy, psychological horror, short.

  5. Storm the SwanPlays here

    Make Cute Animal Friends in this 8-bit Gameboy-inspired adventure! In common: psychological horror, atmospheric, 2d.

  6. Closing DoorsPlays on collarpill.itch.io

    The elevator stops, even though this isn't your floor. In common: creepy, atmospheric, short.

  7. The Dark Path to the Black TowerPlays on scary-pixels.itch.io

    Anomaly horror with a dark fantasy theme. In common: creepy, atmospheric, pixel art.

  8. NasubiPlays on funbanan.itch.io

    YOU TOOK PART IN A CONTROVERSIAL TV SHOW. In common: creepy, psychological horror, atmospheric.

  9. Due DatePlays on clov.itch.io

    Your Art assignment is due in 20 seconds... In common: atmospheric, short, 2d.

  10. FuneramaPlays on thibault-rivera.itch.io

    Step into the sick mind of a novelist As her inner world slowly falls into ruin, step into the mind of Othilie Wynne, a once-successful novelist obsessed with… In common: creepy, psychological horror, atmospheric.

All matches

Every game like The Tooth Fae

Back to The Tooth Fae →