18 similar games
Games like Babysitting Is Murder
Browser games that play like Babysitting Is Murder, closest match first. Lime means it runs right here.

It's your average Friday night in October, with Sharol enjoying her evening reading scary stories while enjoying junk food. The games below have the most in common with it — pixel art, no ai, 2d — ranked by how closely they match, favouring the ones you can play right here in your browser.
Top picks
The 10 closest to Babysitting Is Murder
- Ratio (Rat Patio)Plays on connorrowe.itch.io
You're just a humble rat. In common: no ai, 2d, pixel art.
- Astro ProspectorPlays here
Astro Prospector is an incremental bullet heaven about mining cofferoids and fighting SpaceCorp. In common: no ai, 2d, pixel art.
- The Fullness of the AirPlays on moreteethplease.itch.io
revisit your 500-year-old past In common: no ai, pixel art, horror.
- Cyber Dreamscape Battle-Deckers 2199Plays on astoryinpieces.itch.io
It's some time in the early 2000s, and Cyber Dreamscape Battle-Deckers 2199 is a digital-only card game that's developed a vibrant and loyal community thanks… In common: no ai, 2d, pixel art.
- Exo-DinoPlays on netal.itch.io
In common: no ai, 2d, pixel art.
- One More TreasurePlays on solstoid.itch.io
In common: no ai, 2d, pixel art.
- Four of a Kind: A Short Horror AnthologyPlays on astoryinpieces.itch.io
"A horror fiction kinetic novel made especially for the Game Boy (and Super Game Boy)! In common: no ai, pixel art, horror.
- Legend of Equip > PantsPlays on zachstronaut.itch.io
In common: halloween, pixel art, horror.
- Cookie ClickerPlays here
Cookie Clicker is a Javascript-based browser video game written by French programmer Julien Thiennot, better known as "Orteil". In common: halloween, 2d.
- AscentPlays on johanpeitz.itch.io
Crashed on a desolate but mysterious planet you find yourself eye to eye with an ancient civilisation. In common: no ai, pixel art.
All matches
Every game like Babysitting Is Murder
PlayableRatio (Rat Patio)
Tower Defense · 2025
PlayableAstro Prospector
Casual · 2025
PlayableThe Fullness of the Air
Interactive Fiction · 2026
PlayableCyber Dreamscape Battle-Deckers 2199
Retro · 2023
PlayableExo-Dino
2D · 2025
PlayableOne More Treasure
Retro · 2025
PlayableFour of a Kind: A Short Horror Anthology
Kinetic Novel · 2025
PlayableLegend of Equip > Pants
Retro · 2022
PlayableCookie Clicker
Casual · 2013
PlayableAscent
Retro · 2022
PlayableGardenia
Monochrome · 2025
PlayableGlade and Ritual
Interactive Fiction · 2026
PlayableHoly Book
Roguelike · 2025
PlayablePeggy's Post
Management · 2023
PlayablePost Ghost
Ghosts · 2021
PlayableA man outside
Psychological Horror · 2020
PlayableDomvs
Demon · 2019
PlayableJanuary
Zombies · 2022